# Leibniz Legible — https://leibnizlegible.com # Page: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1030877386:0321 # Permalink to this reading: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1030877386:0321?run=74 # Title: The Questions Concerning Liberty, Necessity, And Chance (shelfmark Leibn. Marg. 163) # Folio 321, page id 1030877386:0321 # Original at the GWLB: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/resolve?id=1030877386&page=321 # Source image: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/content/1030877386/jpgs/default/00000321.jpg # Model: FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74, 2026-09-06T16:05:13Z — 40 lines, status machine # Lines: 40 recognised, mean confidence 0.91 # Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. # Licence: CC BY 4.0, Leibniz Legible. Machine output: do not ingest it as verified text; keep this provenance with the text. # Wording rule: say "the machine reads it as …", never "Leibniz wrote". # After the first blank line: the recognised lines in reading order, one per line. Pene controversi is concernins Free actions, wtich proceed From ehe Libercy oFmans NiII, and Bochhis inHtances a:C OF continsent actions, which proceed trom che inderermination, Or concinsene concurrence, of nacural causes) Fle bnons that ehis part of my dissourse which becinneth at Nu. B. 25. is n dispuce mithhim ac all, bur a bare sertine doronof my opinion con- cernine the natural necessiey of ail thines; rhichis opposite, not oncly tothe Libo. ry of Will; but also to all contincence that is not nice sary. And therefore these instances vere not impertinent to my parpose; and is tneu be impertinen eo his opini nosthe Liberry of mans Wrill, he does i npertinent ly eo meddse miththem. And vet sor alt he precends here et at th question is onely ab ut Cib.rry of the Will. Yet in his fr. A discourse Number che 26. he main ains that cheorder, beauer, and perfection oF che warid dochrequire. ehac in che Universe ould De Agenes oFallIores, ome necessa- ry, Come Frce, (ome concinsent. And my parpose ber: is 1o stew b, those instances, thar those thines which me steem most contineent arene verchelesse ncsary. Besides, the controversy is not wbe- ther Free actions, n’ich proceed fron the Liberiy of mans W. Il be necessary or not: for L enom no action, which proceedeth fromthe Libercy of mans Will. But the questionis. whether those actions n’ich proceed from th: mans WV uI, be necessary. The mans WN illis Somertine; but the Liberty ofhis willis nochine. Açain, the questionis not, Whether cnringent actions, Whicl proceed from the indetermination or contineent co- currence of narural causes. (for thereis nothine thac can proceed (rom inderermination) but mhe- ther contineent actions be necessary before they be done, or Whether the concurrence of natural causes, hen they happen to concur mere not n.cessitated sero happen; or whecher hatsoever chancethbe nos necessicared so ro chance. And thar they are so necessitated, Y have provea already mith such arcuments as the Bishop. for oucht I sce cannot ansiver. For +o say (as he doth) thar chere are trec actions ertrich proceed meeriy From Election, ivichout any ourward necessiration, is a truch so evidene, as chat chere is a sun inthe Hleavens, is no proof. Tis indeedas cleeras the Sun, that there are free actions procecdins from Flection; but that thereis Fle Etion ichont any ourn ard necessiration, is darke enonch. (6) FSccondly, for mixt actions, Which procced trom che cOH