# Leibniz Legible — https://leibnizlegible.com # Page: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1066509719:0742 # Permalink to this reading: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1066509719:0742?run=74 # Title: The True Intellectual System Of The Universe (shelfmarks Leibn. Marg. 137, Stück 1; Leibn. Marg. 137) # Folio 722, page id 1066509719:0742 # Original at the GWLB: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/resolve?id=1066509719&page=742 # Source image: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/content/1066509719/jpgs/default/00000742.jpg # Model: FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74, 2026-09-06T16:05:13Z — 60 lines, status machine # Lines: 60 recognised, mean confidence 0.89 # Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. # Licence: CC BY 4.0, Leibniz Legible. Machine output: do not ingest it as verified text; keep this provenance with the text. # Wording rule: say "the machine reads it as …", never "Leibniz wrote". # After the first blank line: the recognised lines in reading order, one per line. Aeainst ihe Carrelian BoOKI. in our omn minds, OE an absoluletus Persect Beine, includine Neceltary Exiltence in ic, it will not ac all Follo From thence, THAE chereFOTE there is such a Perfect Beine Really Pxiltins withour our minds; We beins able eo frame in our mindsthe Ideas oF many other chinss, thac never vere, nor will Be. AII thac ean be certaiuly inferred From che Idea OF a perfect Beine Ceemsto be this, thac it it contain nochins rhich is contradictions to ic, then it is Not Impossible buc chac there might be such a Beins actually Existing. But chesrengck ot ehis arsument, noc lyins neerly in chis, chat becaule we have an sdeaos a Persect Beins, theretore it is; but becaule me have lueta an Idea oF il, a5 includeth Necessary Existence in ic, Which the Idea ot Nochins else behides doch; cheretore may it be here Further Object cd in this manner. Thatthoush ic be very true, chac a Perfect Be- ins dothinclude Necessary Fxistence in it, because chat cannot be cve- ry may persect, Whole Existence is nOt Necessary bur contineent; yet Wrill it noc Pollon trom hence, chac cheretore thereis such a Persect Beine Actnally Existine; buc all ehac can be deduced trom ic, will bC nomore chan chis, Thac whatloever hath no Necessary and Eternal FX. istence, is no Absolutely Perfect Being; and again, Phac IF there bC any absoluiely Perseet Beins, then was its Existence alvays Necessary arid illbe alvars such; chac is, ic did both Exist OF it self, Prom all F. ternier wichout Beginmins, and mult needs Exist to Pternicy Tncor- ruptibly; ic beins never able to cease to bc. It scems indecd no more totollon, Thacbecause a Perfect Beiny includes necellarr P’n iltence in its Idea, cheretore there is such a Perfect Beine Actually Existins; chan because a Pertect Beins includes Necessary Omniscience andomnipotence in it, chat theretore there is (uch a Perteet Omnilcient and Omnipotent Beins: als thac Folloms in boch cases, beins ouly this; chac IE chere Bc any Beins absolutely perfect, then ic is boch Omnilcient and Omipotent, and ic did Exist OF IE sels necellarily; and can never Ceale to bc. Wheretore here lies a Fallaer in this argumentation, When trom che Necessity oC Existence attirmed ontr Hypothetically Ox upon a Supposition OF a Pertect Beins, ihe ConcluH on is made concernins it Absolurety. AS Tome vould prove che NC- cestiey oF alI huMAHC LVenES, aS FOr example oF adams Sinnine, I ehis manner, thac it alvars as Frue belore, that cither Adam mould eat the Forbidden truit, Or not eat it, and IF he mould cat it, He rould Cextainly eat ic, and not Contingently; and again, IE he vould noc eat ic, then mould he Certainly and Necellarily not Fat it; Wheretore whether he will eat it or noc eat it, he will do cither, Necessarily and noc Continsentlr. Where icisplain, that an abso. Inte Necessitu, is vronely interred in che conclusion, Erom an H, pothe tical one in the premisses. In litce manner, irhen uxon supposition ol an absolutely Persect Beins, it is aftirmed OF ic, chat ils Existence mult nOE DC Contingent but Necessary, and From thence che Conclusion is made absolutelr, chac there lo such a Perfect Being, this SCCmS LO BC ThC very Came Fallacy. From che Idea of a Persect Beins, includine Necessars Existence in ic, ic follons undeniably, thac lF cherebe any Thins Ab. Tolucely Perfect, ic Must Exist Necellarily, and noc Contingently, bue it doch noc sollon, chat chere Must of Necessity Be such a P ertect BCIBS Fxiltins; chese crro Propolicions carryins a very ditterent sense trom OBE erselt ip clore de le itr dic