# Leibniz Legible — https://leibnizlegible.com # Page: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1066509719:0883 # Permalink to this reading: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1066509719:0883?run=74 # Title: The True Intellectual System Of The Universe (shelfmarks Leibn. Marg. 137, Stück 1; Leibn. Marg. 137) # Folio 863, page id 1066509719:0883 # Original at the GWLB: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/resolve?id=1066509719&page=883 # Source image: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/content/1066509719/jpgs/default/00000883.jpg # Model: FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74, 2026-09-06T16:05:13Z — 51 lines, status machine # Lines: 51 recognised, mean confidence 0.91 # Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. # Licence: CC BY 4.0, Leibniz Legible. Machine output: do not ingest it as verified text; keep this provenance with the text. # Wording rule: say "the machine reads it as …", never "Leibniz wrote". # After the first blank line: the recognised lines in reading order, one per line. CHA P. V. Substantiallier of alt Souls. Doronmards eopwards; andtheretore is it atheistical; and by che Same reaton, chac One Hieher Rank or Degree in ihis Scale, is chyS unnacurally Produccd trom a Lover, may aIl the rest bc (0 prody. ced al(o. Wheretore me have great reason to stand upon our Ouard here, and eo desend ehis Post againt che stheists; THaC nO Life OF Copitation, con cicher Materially or efficiently resule trom Dead and Senstess Body; Or chac Souls beins all Substantial, aud immateriat chings, can neither BC Gencrated OUL OF MACLEE, nor Corrupted into the lame, but only created or annihilated by che Deity. The Grand Objection against ehis Substantialisy oF Souls Sensitive 25 Wellas Rational, is From chat Consequence, whieh will BCFrom chence inferred, oP cheir Permanent Subsistence atterDeath, cheir P er- Decuitr, or immorcalier. Thisscemine very absurd, chacthe Soyle OE Brutes al(o ould De immorral, or lubsist aftex ihC DeatHS OF thC Respectire animals: Buc especially e0 Tvo SortS OF MCn; PirH. Such as scarcely in rood carnest beliere, their omn Souls immortali- ey; and Secondly, such Religionists, as conclude, chat il Prrationa ox Senfitive Souls, suBlst atrer Death, then must chey necds 80 pre- Tenelr, cicher intoHeaven orHelI. And R. Carrestus was (o sentible OE the ossensiveness oF chis opinion, chac choush he vere Fully convinced oF the necestuy oF ihis Disjunction, chac cither Brutes have nochine of Sense or Cogitation ac aIl, or elle chey must have lome other Substance in ehem besides Master, he chole rather io make ehem meer Senstess Machins, inen co allom ehem Substantial Souls. Wherein aroiding a Cesser absurdity or Paradox, he plainly plunged himsele into a Oreater; Scarcely any ching beinz more generally re- ceived, chanche sense oF Brutes. Thouoh in cruch aI chose, Wrho de- nr the Substantialiey oE Sensirive Souls, and will have Brutes 1o have nochins buc Master in chem, oughe consequeney accordins coRealon todo 25 Cartestus did, deprire chem oF aIL Sense. BuE On ThCCONETAEY. iC ic be evident From che PhanOmena, THaE BEULCS AECNOLMCCE Sen(- less Machins or Antomata, and only likee elocks or Watches, chen ouxhe noc Popular Opinion and rulcar Prejudice (0 Far to prerail with 15, a5 10 hinder our Alent, tothat which Pound Reason and Philo(ophy elearir dictares chac cheretore cher must have Comethins more chan Matter in chem. Neicher oughe we, irhen e clearly conceire anx chins 10 becrue, aschis, That Lise and Cogiration cannot postibly rile, out oF Dead and senstess Marrer; to abandon ic, or deny our ACent chereunto because we sind it accende d with (ome Ditticuler, not casily Pxeri- cable br us or cannot Frec aIl the Consequences thereot From Come Inconvenience or Absurdiey, such as seems eo be in the Permanent Subsistence oF Brutisto Souls. For the sivine an AccounEOF etich nocmichstandine, Plato ane ihe Ancient Pythaeoreans, proposed ehis Collomins Hy pothesis. ThaL Touls a5 Well Sensitive, as Rational, beins all Substantial, buEnOE SeI(- existent. (because there is buc one Fountain, and Principle oF aII Chines) were cheretore Produced or Caused by che Deity. But this; noc in che Generations oF che respectire Animals; it beins indeco. rons chac chis Dirine Miraculons Creasive Porer, Mould constanciy lacquey