# Leibniz Legible — https://leibnizlegible.com # Page: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/778263916:0059 # Permalink to this reading: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/778263916:0059?run=74 # Title: An Essay Concerning Humane Understanding (shelfmarks Leibn. Marg. 38; ZEN Leibn. Marg. 38) # Folio 43, page id 778263916:0059 # Original at the GWLB: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/resolve?id=778263916&page=59 # Source image: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/content/778263916/jpgs/default/00000059.jpg # Model: FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74, 2026-09-06T16:05:13Z — 55 lines, status machine # Lines: 55 recognised, mean confidence 0.90 # Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. # Licence: CC BY 4.0, Leibniz Legible. Machine output: do not ingest it as verified text; keep this provenance with the text. # Wording rule: say "the machine reads it as …", never "Leibniz wrote". # After the first blank line: the recognised lines in reading order, one per line. Men thinz not alvays. Mnrro Ideas, derired trom che Body, and the Operations ol the Mind about them, or else that the soul remembers lomethins that the Man does NOF. 6. F8. Lirouldbeglad also to learn trom thele men, irho loconsidentr pro- riounce, has the humane Soul, Or, ertich is all one, that a man alvazsthints, hor ther core tohno it; naz, hou theycome totenou that theythemselves thinte, When therthemselves donorperceive it. This, lam atroid; isto belure, Without proots; and to krion, Wichout percciving: Tis. I suspect, a contuled Nocion, taken up to serve an Frpothelis; and none olthole clear PrutHs; chat cither their omn Pridencetorce us to admit, or common Experience makres it impudence to deny. Porthe most that can be saidot it, is, Phat tis Possiblethe Soul may abvazs think, but not almazs retain it in memory: And, Ilay, it is as possible, that the Soul may nor alvazs chinke; and much more probable, that it ould Cometimes not thinte, than thac it strould osten thinkc, and that a lons Wrhile together, and not be consci- ous Eo it se lFThe next momene atter, that it had thousht. 6. F9. Fo suppole the Soul eo chint, and the Nan noc perceire it, i5, ishas been Paid, Eo malce eiro persons in one man: And il one consider elletiese mens ay of speakeins, one MalI be lead into a suspicion, chat therdoso. For ther whotellus, thatthe soul alrays chinks, do never, that Premember, (ay, That a man alvazs chinks. Can the Soul chintis and nocthe Man: Or a Man think, and noc be conscious of it: This, per- haps, ould De suspected oF farcon in others. IF they Pay, The man chints alvars, buc is not alvazs conscious of it; ther may as vell Car, FTis Body is extended, without havins Parts. For tis altogetheras intellisible to Pay, that any chins is extended without pares, as that ans chins thintes, with out beine conscious of it; Withour perceivins, chat it does (0. They whotalke thus, may, rith as much reason, il it be necessarr to their FypochelIs fay, Fhataman is alrars hunger, but that he does not alvars seel it: Whereas hunger consicts in that very senlation, as thinkins consilts in ber ins conscious chat one thinles. IPthey CaY, That a man is alivars consci ous tohimseloF chinkcins; Paste, Fron ther lnow ic: Conscioulnels is the perception oF wrhat passes in a mans omn mind. Can another man perceire, chat Pam conscious of ans chine, irhen lperceire it not my selt: Nomans know ledse here, ean so berond his Fxperience. Wakc a man OuE OF a Cound PlCep, and asE him, What he was char momene thinking on. iEhe himselE be conscious oFnochins he then thought on, he must BC d nocable Diriner oE Thouetus, that can alture him, that he rras thin- hins: May he not wich more reason alture him, he ras not aslcep: This is Lomethins berond Philolophy; and it cannot be lels than Revelation, thar discovers to another, Thoughes in my mind, wrhen P can And none there my selF: And they must necds have a penetratins sight, who can cerrainly sec, That P chinE, Wwhen P cannor perceive il my selt, and declare, Thac I do noc; and vet can sec, that aD05, or an Flephant, do not thinl, chouoh eley gire all the demonstration ofit imasinable, exceptonsy relling us, that thes do (o. This lome mar sulpect tobe à ser bexond the Rosecrucians; it sceming casier to makre ones sels invisible tO OtherS; thaM comake another schouslis visibleto me, whichare nor visible cohim selF. BUE eis bur detinine the Soul to be a substance, thac alvazs thinks, and tlie businessis done. TF such a definition be oE any Authorier, TknoW nOE Wvhat it can serre for; buc to matce mans men suspect, That they hare no Souls ac all, since chey Aind a sood part oftheir Lives pals avaz witt out chinkins. For no Vetinitions, that Pknow, no Suppolitions oF any Sect, are oi soree cnoustro destroy constant Eisperience; and, pertraps