# Leibniz Legible — https://leibnizlegible.com # Page: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/778263916:0323 # Permalink to this reading: https://leibnizlegible.com/page/778263916:0323?run=74 # Title: An Essay Concerning Humane Understanding (shelfmarks Leibn. Marg. 38; ZEN Leibn. Marg. 38) # Folio 307, page id 778263916:0323 # Original at the GWLB: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/resolve?id=778263916&page=323 # Source image: https://digitale-sammlungen.gwlb.de/content/778263916/jpgs/default/00000323.jpg # Model: FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74, 2026-09-06T16:05:13Z — 51 lines, status machine # Lines: 51 recognised, mean confidence 0.89 # Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. # Licence: CC BY 4.0, Leibniz Legible. Machine output: do not ingest it as verified text; keep this provenance with the text. # Wording rule: say "the machine reads it as …", never "Leibniz wrote". # After the first blank line: the recognised lines in reading order, one per line. vistine Croposition. H A L. Os Tristins Proposuions. V 3. F. TX Y Hecher the Maxims create d oE in the Pore Foins Chapter, Be oEthat use to real Rnomledse, as is generalr suppoled, sequetobe considered. This, Pchink, may considently Be astirmed, That there are universal Propolirions; that thoush thes be certainly truc, ver elier acd no lighe ro our Onderstandinss, brins no increale tO OurHnoW- ledoe. Such arc, 6. 2. First. Ml purely identicat Propositions. These obviousty, arid at first Blustr, avpear to contain no Instruction in them. For wtien we rf Firm the Came Ferr oE it selF, Whether it be barely verbal, or irhecter ic contains any clear and real Laea, it Pers us nothing, but erhat we must certaintr Rnor belore, Wrhecher such a Proposition be cither made By, Or propoled to us. Indced, chac most general one, What is, is, may serve Coretimmes to Mer a Man the absurdier he is guiley oF, when by circum. locution, or equivocal terms, he voule, in particular instances, deny ché Same ching oFic selF; becaule no bods irill (o oxenly Bid detiance to com- mon sense, as to attirm visible and direct Contradictions in plain Nords: Or ifhedoes, a Man is exculed il ho break oA anY farther discourse wict him. But vet, I chink, Imay Cay, chat neither that received Maxim, nox any other identical Propolirion, reaches usans chins: And thoush in such kind of Propolitions, this sreat and masnisicd Maxim, boasted 10 De theToundarion ot Demonstration, may be, and olten is ade ulc OF+0 contirm Fhem, Vet aIL IE PrOVeS, aOUnES EO nO more chan thIS, THat the same Word maz rith great certainty be assirmed oF it selF, Wittout any doube of ihe Truch or any such Proposition; and let me ac al(0, ithout any real Rnorledse. 6. 3. Forat this rate, any very ionorant person, Who ean but malie a Proposition, and linors What he means irhen he lays AY, Or NO, mav malce a million of Propositions, oP whose Truth he may be infallibly cer cain, and y et not lnor one chins in the Worid cherebs; 2. 8. Wrtrat is a Soul, isa Soul; or a Soul, is a Soul; a Spirit, is a Spirit; a Fetiche, is a Fetichie, Cc. Fhele allbeins equivalent tothis Provolicion, viz. Wbat is is, i. C. Wtrat hach Existence, hath Existence; or Wrho hach a Soul, hatha Soul. WNhat is this more chan tristins rith Nords. It is bur libse a Monber Thisting his Oystertrom onc hand tothe orher; and had he hact but Worcs, miglt, no doube, have said, Oyster in riohe hand is subject, and Oyster in lest hand is predicate: and (o mighe have made a tell. evident Provo(- tion of Oyster, i. c. Oyster is Oylter; and zet, ith all this, noc have been one Whit che miser, or morelnowins: and elac war ol hrandline the inacter, vould much at one have latistied the Monteys Clunger, or a Maris Onderstandine; and ther vould have improved in Hnomledee and bulk tossether. 8. 4. Secondir, Anocher Tort oEtristins Propolirions is, nhena part of the complex Idea is predicated of the Name of the Wwhole; 2. Pare oF ehie de- finition oF the Word detined. Such are all Propolitions eherein the Cenus is predicated ofthe Species, or more compreliensive of lels compre- hensive icems: For Whac tulormalion. What Vinouledge cncries Ehis Psc. Position