Search the Nachlass

The Questions Concerning Liberty, Necessity, And Chance, fol. 275

Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. Mean line confidence on this page: 0.92.

Original at the GWLB · Page image · Annotations (IIIF) · Download text

The machine reads it as

  1. (e) PThat Which he saith, chac the action doch necessarit,
  2. follem the thonghe, is thus far erue, chac chose actions which are
  3. altosecher undeliberaced, and do procecd trom violent pasi-
  4. Ons, Ec. are noc properly, and actually in chemlelvestree, bur
  5. racher necessary actions; a5 nten a manruns away Erom 2
  6. Cat Or a custard) Thus far he says is erne. Dut whenh: cas
  7. Sudden passiens mocus primo primi, Tcannet teIl wherher heCq
  8. true or not, because I do not undrstand him, nor fin l ho he makes
  9. his meanins ever the clearer by his example of a Ca: ans a C u-
  10. stard; becanse Lenov not what he means by a secret Antipathie.
  11. For iohat that Antipathy is he explainethnot by calii. s it sceret,
  12. but rather confesseth he bnoms nor hom to explainit. And becanse
  13. hesairh it is chus Far erue, Lexpect he Bould rell me also l’on far
  14. it is false.
  15. (Secondly, as for those actions, wherein actual delibe-
  16. rarion seems noc necellary, becanse never any thine appeared
  17. that conla mate a man doubt ofthe consequence, I do confelle,
  18. thac Actions done by rertue oF a precedent deliberation, wict.
  19. ouc any actual deliberarion For che presene, may normithstan.
  20. dins be eruels, voluncary and tree ActS.) In this he acrees
  21. vith me. Dut vohere he adds, vea, in Pome cases, and in Pome
  22. sense more Free, chen if cher vere actually deliberared oF in
  23. Prelent, Ido not acree vithhim. And for the instance he brincech
  24. 10 provo it, in the man that playeth on an i strument rith bis
  25. hand it maketh nothine forhim; for it provethonely tbat the TLa-
  26. bir maheth che motion ofhishand, more reary and quicle; but it
  27. proveth not rhat it makethit more voluntari, but rather lesse, be-
  28. cause cherest os the motions follom che first, by an casinesse acquired
  29. from lone custome; in rhich motion the Wil doth not accompany all
  30. the strokes of thehand, but zives a becinnine rothem one ly in the
  31. first. Flere is nothine as Lexpectedof hom far that mhich Thad
  32. Caid, namely, that the action doth necessarily follon thethoueht; is
  33. faise, unlesse it beimpropriecies of speccti, a5 callins chat volun
  34. cary whichiis frec, and liictins ehe will eo che lalt appecite;
  35. and ocher mistates, 25, chac no aet can be said eo be wichout
  36. deliberation. For improprieties of specch, L will not contend m: th
  37. one, that can use mocus primo primi, practice practicum, actus
  38. elicirus, and many other phrases of the same kind. But so say that
  39. Mm
  40. Fret

Cite

The Questions Concerning Liberty, Necessity, And Chance, fol. 275. Machine transcription, not an edition: Leibniz Legible (model FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74). https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1030877386:0275?run=74