Search the Nachlass

The Questions Concerning Liberty, Necessity, And Chance, fol. 321

Machine transcription. Not an edition. Errors are expected: about 8% character error rate on Latin and French lines, higher on German. Mean line confidence on this page: 0.91.

Original at the GWLB · Page image · Annotations (IIIF) · Download text

The machine reads it as

  1. Pene controversi is concernins Free actions, wtich proceed
  2. From ehe Libercy oFmans NiII, and Bochhis inHtances a:C OF
  3. continsent actions, which proceed trom che inderermination,
  4. Or concinsene concurrence, of nacural causes) Fle bnons that
  5. ehis part of my dissourse which becinneth at Nu. B. 25. is n
  6. dispuce mithhim ac all, bur a bare sertine doronof my opinion con-
  7. cernine the natural necessiey of ail thines; rhichis opposite, not
  8. oncly tothe Libo. ry of Will; but also to all contincence that is not
  9. nice sary. And therefore these instances vere not impertinent to my
  10. parpose; and is tneu be impertinen eo his opini nosthe Liberry of
  11. mans Wrill, he does i npertinent ly eo meddse miththem. And vet sor
  12. alt he precends here et at th question is onely ab ut Cib.rry of the
  13. Will. Yet in his fr. A discourse Number che 26. he main ains that
  14. cheorder, beauer, and perfection oF che warid dochrequire.
  15. ehac in che Universe ould De Agenes oFallIores, ome necessa-
  16. ry, Come Frce, (ome concinsent. And my parpose ber: is 1o stew
  17. b, those instances, thar those thines which me steem most contineent
  18. arene verchelesse ncsary. Besides, the controversy is not wbe-
  19. ther Free actions, n’ich proceed fron the Liberiy of mans W. Il be
  20. necessary or not: for L enom no action, which proceedeth fromthe
  21. Libercy of mans Will. But the questionis. whether those actions
  22. n’ich proceed from th: mans WV uI, be necessary. The mans WN illis
  23. Somertine; but the Liberty ofhis willis nochine. Açain, the
  24. questionis not, Whether cnringent actions, Whicl proceed from the
  25. indetermination or contineent co- currence of narural causes. (for
  26. thereis nothine thac can proceed (rom inderermination) but mhe-
  27. ther contineent actions be necessary before they be done, or Whether
  28. the concurrence of natural causes, hen they happen to concur mere
  29. not n.cessitated sero happen; or whecher hatsoever chancethbe nos
  30. necessicared so ro chance. And thar they are so necessitated, Y have
  31. provea already mith such arcuments as the Bishop. for oucht I sce
  32. cannot ansiver. For +o say (as he doth) thar chere are trec actions
  33. ertrich proceed meeriy From Election, ivichout any ourward
  34. necessiration, is a truch so evidene, as chat chere is a sun inthe
  35. Hleavens, is no proof. Tis indeedas cleeras the Sun, that there
  36. are free actions procecdins from Flection; but that thereis Fle
  37. Etion ichont any ourn ard necessiration, is darke enonch.
  38. (6)
  39. FSccondly, for mixt actions, Which procced trom che
  40. cOH

Cite

The Questions Concerning Liberty, Necessity, And Chance, fol. 321. Machine transcription, not an edition: Leibniz Legible (model FoNDUE-GD_v2_ft_Leibniz, run 74). https://leibnizlegible.com/page/1030877386:0321?run=74